Atheists Who Celebrate All The Good That God Causes.

Discussion in 'Religion & Philosophy' started by JAG*, May 25, 2020.

  1. Swensson

    Swensson Devil's advocate

    Joined:
    Dec 16, 2009
    Messages:
    8,176
    Likes Received:
    1,075
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Gender:
    Male
    Sailed? When was the ship ever here? I asked you to show it as soon as you made any claims about what these atheists believe. Mighty convenient that you allowed the "ship" to slip away. I'd say if you can't show it, then you don't actually have a leg to stand on, and your argument falls through.

    How so? My point is that you can't seem to draw the line between them, so if you describe one, it tells me something about what you think about the other.

    So? My point isn't that I'm going to create a catalogue of all beliefs held by atheists, my point is that I understand the structure behind the atheists' views to the point where I can consistently predict it. I'm not claiming that it is true for 100% of atheists, or that one can't modify one's belief, I'm merely saying that your claim of 99.99% of atheists is false, not only literally (which I think you already agreed to) but also figuratively. In fact, I think you'll be hard pressed to find even one (I may have to eat those words, I'm sure the odd person out exists).

    If it turns out that I'm right, that in fact the majority of atheists believe what I suggest, then it shows that your understanding of why atheists say what they say, and what principles they adhere to is wrong, and they don't actually say anything inconsistent by pointing out 1-12.

    Oh, so when the questions become inconvenient, you no longer take it seriously. Imagine if that was a good approach to any conversation. "Don't kill innocent people!" "Eh, I don't really take that seriously".

    I don't see that puts me in any worse situation than it puts you. The "99.99%" of atheists you were talking about (which then turned out to be so few that you can't even find an example of it) could be lying to you (or, I think more to the point, you may have simply misunderstood what their position is).

    I am well aware of this, and have been since the first post. Read the bit you quoted again. I'm not asking you to repeat that you will talk about hospitals rather than kelp, I'm asking you why you make that distinction. But here is the answer, and you have either failed to read my post or deliberately avoided answering it. Again.
     
  2. Swensson

    Swensson Devil's advocate

    Joined:
    Dec 16, 2009
    Messages:
    8,176
    Likes Received:
    1,075
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Gender:
    Male
    I can tell you a few things you can expect. I am not doing it by imposing "authority" on you, certainly not any more than you are imposing on the atheists. However, I can provide the evidence of people showing me that I'm right about what most atheists think.
    I have questioned the parts of the post that I think were wrong, are you suggesting that I am not in a position to do that? The behaviour of the atheists makes its way into the thread title and the conclusion of the OP, hardly a red herring.
    It has everything to do with your opening post. It shows that the logic you present, your 14 points has nothing to do with the fact that atheists do not see fit to "join you in listing the good things God causes" or 'celebrate all the good that God does "if God does exist."', which is the conclusion of your OP.
    I'm confused over you repeating your point about "asking" or "requesting". Are you under the impression that my points would at all be addressed by that wording?
    We seem to have different understandings of what celebration means. Would you say that you "celebrate" 2+2=4? Do you think that others do?
     
  3. trevorw2539

    trevorw2539 Well-Known Member Past Donor

    Joined:
    Jul 15, 2013
    Messages:
    8,299
    Likes Received:
    1,257
    Trophy Points:
    113
    36 pages of discussion on an assumption - that God exists. Would it not be better to prove the existence of God first. and then pose the question as to why atheists celebrate the good things God provides.
    Should I celebrate Harry Potters victory over the evil Voldemort. Harry Potter must have existed because I've read about him and even been to his world near London.
    Assumptions are just that - until proven true.
     
    Jolly Penguin and Ronald Hillman like this.
  4. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    It does not matter what atheists believe.
    It does not matter what principles they use.
    It does not matter what you claim is consistent or inconsistent.
    It does not matter how many atheists you can get to tell you what they believe.
    It does not matter how many atheists that you claim are on your side.
    Here is what does matter:
    My 11 down there matters.
    Many atheists DO say my 11
    If they say 11, then it MUST follow that 12 and 14 are true.
    There is nothing you can say that will prove this false.


    {1) I am an atheist.
    {2} i don't believe in God.
    {3} But He may exist.
    {4} I can't prove He does.
    {5} I can't prove He doesn't.
    {6} The Bible says He is Omnipotent.
    {7} That means He is all powerful.
    {8} He could have created a different world.
    {9} But He did not do that.
    {10} He created the world we now have.
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.
    {12} Therefore God is responsible for bone cancer in children.
    {13} I want to be consistent with this principle.
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross

    ______________

    "My point is NOT that God IS good or that God IS evil.
    My point is that God PERFORMS both good and evil acts
    based upon {6} through {14}. Remember {6} through {12}
    is what atheist say --- {6} through {12} is NOT what JAG
    says. I do NOT have to be consistent with a position
    that I do NOT hold. But atheists do. Why? because they
    DO hold {6} through {12} to be true and they DO advocate
    for {6} through {12} all the time in threads on the
    Internet At large."___JAG

    ____________

    Good to see you back Swensson.

    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.
    Remember many atheists DO say 11 is true, and if 11 is
    true, then the God-That-Does-Not-Exist is responsible
    for cancer and Hospitals and the Red Cross. Fact.

    JAG
     
  5. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    False.
    You do not know what the OP is about.
    You have no clue.
    Your reading comprehension has already been demonstrated to be poor.

    Also you seem to dislike the subject of this thread.
    You seem to dislike this thread. And the OP.
    Are you aware that thread participation is 100% voluntary?
    Is there some Force that is pulling you over here?
    You do have a Free Will, do you not?
    So you could choose not to read that which you claim
    to believe is unnecessary.

    Go start a thread on that.
    What is keeping you from starting your own thread on what you
    think is "better"?
    This thread has got NOTHING to do with proving the existence of God.
    Where is YOUR thread on that?

    This thread is NOT about your "why."
    Once again your reading comprehension is very poor.
    You have zero understanding of what this OP is about.
    But you post on it anyway.
    You have not comprehended my many posts in this thread,
    yet you continue to "hold forth" on the OP with your ignorance
    regarding what the OP seeks to accomplish.
    "Each man hears what he wants to hear, and disregards the rest."__Bob Dylan
    Your posts demonstrates that truth perfectly.
    You hear what you want to hear, and you disregard the facts


    JAG States What many Atheists Say:
    {1) I am an atheist.
    {2} i don't believe in God.
    {3} But He may exist.
    {4} I can't prove He does.
    {5} I can't prove He doesn't.
    {6} The Bible says He is Omnipotent.
    {7} That means He is all powerful.
    {8} He could have created a different world.
    {9} But He did not do that.
    {10} He created the world we now have.
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.
    {12} Therefore God is responsible for bone cancer in children.
    {13} I want to be consistent with this principle.
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross

    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.
    Remember many atheists DO say 11 is true, and if 11 is
    true, then the God-That-Does-Not-Exist is responsible
    for cancer and Hospitals and the Red Cross. Fact.

    That demonstrates that you do not know what you are talking about.
    That demonstrates that your reading comprehension skills are very poor.
    You said previously that you had read many discussions between me and
    Swensson ---and I have posted my 1 - 14 , , , MANY times, but you
    IGNORED it and "saw only what you wanted to see."
    It has been explained to you many times that some
    atheists postulate that God exist for the sake of
    argument and then they proceed to state my 6-12.
    So? So for you to say "36 pages of discussion on an
    assumption -- that God exists" is absurd nonsense.


    JAG States What many Atheists Say:
    {1) I am an atheist.
    {2} i don't believe in God.
    {3} But He may exist.
    {4} I can't prove He does.
    {5} I can't prove He doesn't
    .

    ______

    {By the way, you do the same thing with your falsely claimed
    knowledge of the historical background of the Bible. Your "facts"
    are lies.}


    PS
    But "not to worry" you are surrounded by "your friends" and they
    will "give you a pass" on ALL your ignorance and on ALL your
    misreading of the OP and all the other clear explanations
    that you choose to IGNORE and they will give you "Thank You's
    because they are members of your atheist tribe and therefore you
    can "do no wrong" in their eyes.

    JAG

    ``
     
    Last edited: Aug 8, 2020
  6. trevorw2539

    trevorw2539 Well-Known Member Past Donor

    Joined:
    Jul 15, 2013
    Messages:
    8,299
    Likes Received:
    1,257
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Taken completely out of context. If, if, if. Assumptions, assumptions, assumptions. If Voldemort exists then we can assume the troubles of the world are down to him. But I don't know anyone who believes Voldemort exists.

    Good heavens. This gets worse.
     
  7. trevorw2539

    trevorw2539 Well-Known Member Past Donor

    Joined:
    Jul 15, 2013
    Messages:
    8,299
    Likes Received:
    1,257
    Trophy Points:
    113
    If it has nothing to do with the existence of God, why all the discussion. If God does not exist humanity is to blame for much of the worlds troubles, and illness is a natural phenomenon. After all didn't Jesus say that the man born blind's state was not the result of his fathers sins. If we are to accept the good things and the bad things as being from God, then we must question the morality of this God. And the first question I would ask is why he created a world so unstable that it regularly kills thousands of his creation, regardless of their status - parents, children, babies. Atheists, Agnostics, Christians.
     
  8. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    2 + 2 = 4 does not have the same level of seriousness and gravity
    as does my 11 down there -- and my 12, 13, and 14

    JAG States What many Atheists Say:
    {1) I am an atheist.
    {2} i don't believe in God.
    {3} But He may exist.
    {4} I can't prove He does.
    {5} I can't prove He doesn't.
    {6} The Bible says He is Omnipotent.
    {7} That means He is all powerful.
    {8} He could have created a different world.
    {9} But He did not do that.
    {10} He created the world we now have.
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.
    {12} Therefore God is responsible for bone cancer in children.
    {13} I want to be consistent with this principle.
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross

    _________

    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.
    Remember many atheists DO say 11 is true, and if 11 is
    true, then the God-That-Does-Not-Exist is responsible
    for cancer and Hospitals and the Red Cross. Fact.

    ___________

    You can't win this by a play on the word "celebrate."
    I am merely asking and requesting that atheists
    OBSERVE something and I am asking them to SAYSOMETING.
    {1} observe something
    {2} say something

    I merely ASK them to SAY 14 if they SAY 11

    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.

    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross


    This is 100% logical and 100% reasonable and it is impossible
    to wiggle and squirm out of that up there.

    Best.

    JAG

    ``
     
    Last edited: Aug 8, 2020
  9. Ronald Hillman

    Ronald Hillman Banned

    Joined:
    Mar 17, 2020
    Messages:
    1,690
    Likes Received:
    1,581
    Trophy Points:
    113
    If God exists then he is responsable for Hospitals and The Red Cross, he is also responsible for all the disease and injuries that make hospital necessary and all the wars that caused the creation of the Red Cross, Happy Now!
     
  10. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    Remain ignorant.
    Double down on your ignorance.
    Continue to post as if the OP does not exist.
    Continue to post as if all my many follow-up posts do not exist.
    Continue to ignore my 1 -14.
    Continue to ignore my 11
    Continue to ignore my 14
    Continue to hear what you want to hear and disregard the rest.


    The fact that you can continue to state your incorrect claim is amazing.

    Your incorrect claim is your continued insistence that this thread is about
    the existence of God , , ,

    , , , rather than being about this:

    ___________________________________________________________
    I merely ASK them to SAY 14 if they SAY 11

    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.

    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross


    This is 100% logical and 100% reasonable and it is impossible
    to wiggle and squirm out of that up there
    .
    ____________________________________________________________


    Continue to ignore that up there.
    Continue to pretend you are a serious responder to the OP.


    Where is YOUR OP on all that?
    What does any of that have to do with my 1 - 14? Answer: NOTHING.
    With my 11 ? NOTHING.
    With my 14 ? NOTHING.
    With my OP ? NOTHING.
    All that is re-hashed Stephen Fry.--- "Bone cancer in children. What's that all about?"
    All that is re-hashed Epicurus.
    All that is re-hashed Dawkins,
    This thread is NOT about your subjects of interest --- but don't let that stop
    you from continuing to "hold forth" on your subjects that have NOTHING
    to do with the OP and with this thread.
    ________

    "then we must question the morality of this God"___trevor
    So where is YOUR OP on that?
    You could title it "The God Of The Bible Is Immoral."

    JAG


    ``
     
  11. Ronald Hillman

    Ronald Hillman Banned

    Joined:
    Mar 17, 2020
    Messages:
    1,690
    Likes Received:
    1,581
    Trophy Points:
    113
    No need to squirm out of it,
    If God exists then he is responsible for Hospitals and The Red Cross, he is also responsible for all the disease and injuries that make hospitals necessary and all the wars that caused the creation of the Red Cross, Happy Now!
     
  12. trevorw2539

    trevorw2539 Well-Known Member Past Donor

    Joined:
    Jul 15, 2013
    Messages:
    8,299
    Likes Received:
    1,257
    Trophy Points:
    113
    I didn't say the OP had anything to do with proving the existence of God. I pointed out that without the proof of the existence of God the whole discussion is pointless. Why discuss your hypothetical points. You are just assuming a God exists. None of your points are relevant to an atheist. I don't. Your post is just one big assumption that god does exist. As I said before it's rather pointless without knowing that God does exist. You can say 'If God.'.. to many things, but without proof it is simply useless chitchat.

    My facts are lies? Then archaeologists, historians and even Christians are lying. Pull yourself together and do some study. You may find - no YOU WILL FIND - that you are the one who is lying.

    PS We have hit a nerve haven't we. Perhaps 'my friends' gve me a pass because they realise that I have studied the Bible et and do know what I'm talking about. All I have posted can be found on line. When I started out many of those facts were simply suppositions. Time, archaeology, modern knowledge and reassessment of the OT as it was written 2,500 years ago has turned those suppositions into facts.
     
    Ronald Hillman likes this.
  13. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    "do not see fit"___Swensson
    They can come to "see fit."
    They may not now "see fit."
    But they may decide to "see fit" tomorrow.
    If not tomorrow, then next week.
    I can ASK them to change their minds.
    I can REQUEST of them that they change their minds.
    I can REQUEST that if they SAY 11, then I ASK that they also SAY 14.
    This is 100% logical and 100% reasonable.

    Please explain to me why this below is not logical/reasonable?
    _____________________________________________________
    I merely ASK them to SAY 14 if they SAY 11

    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.

    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross

    This is 100% logical and 100% reasonable and it is impossible
    to wiggle and squirm out of that up there.

    _________________________________________________________


    {6} The Bible says He is Omnipotent.
    {7} That means He is all powerful.
    {8} He could have created a different world.
    {9} But He did not do that.
    {10} He created the world we now have.
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.
    {12} Therefore God is responsible for bone cancer in children.
    {13} I want to be consistent with this principle.
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross


    I can even REQUEST that they celebrate my 14.
    They can say Yes or No.
    Please explain why it is illogical or unreasonable for me to merely REQUEST that
    atheists celebrate 14 if they SAY 11

    Explain why it is illogical for me to merely REQUEST that atheists
    who DO embrace my 11 , , "That means He is responsible for all that exists."
    also SAY my 14 , , , since when they SAY my 11, they thereby DO embrace
    the PRINCIPLE that is in 11 --- namely that "God is responsible for all that exists."

    If 11 is true, then 14 is also true.

    JAG
     
    Last edited: Aug 8, 2020
  14. Ronald Hillman

    Ronald Hillman Banned

    Joined:
    Mar 17, 2020
    Messages:
    1,690
    Likes Received:
    1,581
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Let me guess any minute now you will be complaining and crying that atheists keep insulting you whilst you continue to post the above!
     
  15. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    Then why are you over here participating in a pointless discussion?
    Also just because YOU say the discussion is pointless, does NOT in fact
    mean that the discussion is pointless. It means rather that YOU do NOT
    understand the OP or the subject of this thread.

    Why are you in this thread?
    You do not even know the hypothetical points are the hypotheticals that
    many atheists present --- and NOT , , , MY , , hypotheticals -- even
    though that has been explained to you MANY times. You still double-down
    on your ignorance.

    Your ignorance of the OP and of the content of my many follow-up posts is astounding.
    At this point, it is clear that you do NOT , , WANT , , to face my 11 and 14 or my 1 -14.
    Rather you want to talk about OTHER subjects that are NOT on the subject of this OP.

    Absurd nonsense.
    Atheists in threads on the Internet At Large PROCLAIM . . 6 - 12 regularly.
    You do not know what you are talking about and that is a FACT.
    But "your friends" will "give you a pass" and still tell you how smart you are.

    Absurd nonsense.
    It has been explained to you many times.
    If 11 is true.
    Then 14 is also true.


    Yet you are still here in this thread.
    Participating in a pointless discussion.
    Still ignoring my 11
    Still ignoring my 14
    Still ignoring 1 -14
    Still ignoring the OP
    Still ignoring my MANY follow-up explanatory posts.


    YOU are no authority on what is, or is not, legitimate proof.
    But if "useless chitchat" why are you here participating in
    useless chitchat?

    Your "facts" are not actually facts.
    Your "facts" are the ant-Christian garbage spewed forth by
    anti-Christian Liberals like Bart Ehrman who hates Christianity
    and hates the Bible and is a Christian apostate -- just like you
    are. You, like Bart, were once a Christian, but you played
    the Judas Card and turned your back on the God that
    created you and turned aside to follow anti-Christian
    apostates like Bart Ehrman. You will regret the day you
    made a Free Will choice to do that. Eternity is going to be
    a long time and you are now 81 years old and you will
    soon know the truth. By the way, your friends will not
    "be there for you" on that day. You will be alone. If you
    die from natural causes, it will not be long before, at
    some point, your doctor shakes his head and walks away.
    You will then be totally alone. To face Eternity without
    the Lord Jesus as your Savior.

    That is what YOU claim to be true.
    It is False.
    There are hundreds of orthodox Bible-believing Christians scholars
    with earned Ph.D's from secular universities that disagree with
    what YOU call "facts."

    You pull yourself together.
    You do some study. Read behind people other than
    anti-Christian "scholars" who have already made up there
    minds BEFORE they even "crack open a book" that they
    are going to be AGAINST Christianity and against the Bible.

    I can say the same thing to you.
    You may find -- no YOU WILL FIND --- that you are the one
    who is lying.

    No "we" have not hit a nerve.
    I pay zero attention to what you say and to what your little band
    of angry frustrated atheists have to say --- which is just more
    hate-filled outbursts of bile and venom and loathing passed off
    as being an intellectual search for the truth.

    If 11 is true, then 14 is also true.

    No.
    They give you a pass because "birds of a feather flock together"
    and they know that YOU are "one of Them" and they will continue
    to give you "moral support" and continue to give you their
    "Thank You's" because you and Them belong to the same ideological
    tribe of atheism.

    Continue to ignore my 11
    Continue to ignore 14
    Continue to ignore 1 -14
    Continue to ignore the OP
    Continue to ignore my many explanatory follow-up posts in this thread.

    JAG

    ``
     
    Last edited: Aug 8, 2020
  16. Ronald Hillman

    Ronald Hillman Banned

    Joined:
    Mar 17, 2020
    Messages:
    1,690
    Likes Received:
    1,581
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Repent or burn, but you will soon be crying about your hurt feelings again, astonishing!
     
  17. Ronald Hillman

    Ronald Hillman Banned

    Joined:
    Mar 17, 2020
    Messages:
    1,690
    Likes Received:
    1,581
    Trophy Points:
    113
    If anyone ever doubts why it is important to expose these fundamentalists for what they are just read this viscous and spiteful attack. So much part of their personality is invested in their god that they cannot bare to be challenged on their ideas. The internet might not be important but it sure brings out the worst in people!
     
    Jolly Penguin and trevorw2539 like this.
  18. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    False.
    You have made a Free Will decision NOT to understand the OP
    and NOT to understand my many follow-up posts.

    And NOT to understand 11
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.

    And NOT to understand 12
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross

    _____________

    You said previously that you had read many discussions between me and
    Swensson ---and I have posted my 1 - 14 , , , MANY times, but you
    IGNORED it and "saw only what you wanted to see."

    It has been explained to you many times that some
    atheists postulate that God exist for the sake of
    argument and then they proceed to state my 6-12.
    So? So for you to say, as you said previously,

    "36 pages of discussion on an assumption -- that
    God exists"
    is willful deliberate ignorance. You

    have made a Free Will decision NOT to face the
    fact that many atheists DO postulate that God
    does exist for the sake of argument. You know
    this is true -- you deliberately refuse to admit
    the truth of it.


    JAG States What Many Atheists Say:
    {1) I am an atheist.
    {2} i don't believe in God.
    {3} But He may exist.
    {4} I can't prove He does.
    {5} I can't prove He doesn't.
    {6} The Bible says He is Omnipotent.
    {7} That means He is all powerful.
    {8} He could have created a different world.
    {9} But He did not do that.
    {10} He created the world we now have.
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.
    {12} Therefore God is responsible for bone cancer in children.
    {13} I want to be consistent with this principle.
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross
    ___________

    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.

    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross

    Remember many atheists DO postulate that God does exist for the sake of argument
    and then they say 1 through 11 is true , , ,

    , , , and if 11 is true then 14 is also true.

    So?

    So the God-That-Does-Not-Exist is responsible
    for cancer and Hospitals and the Red Cross.
    Fact.

    JAG
     
  19. Jolly Penguin

    Jolly Penguin Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jul 17, 2020
    Messages:
    8,333
    Likes Received:
    3,902
    Trophy Points:
    113

    No atheist believes this. If they did, they would by definition not be atheist.

    When we talk about your God, we can only look at him as a fictional character. The version of that character that you endorse can tell us a lot about you, not about any actual God that may or may not exist.

    Actually, Hospitals and the Red Cross are done by humans. I think you'd be better off using rainbows or sunlight as an example.If you claim to credit your God for hospitals and the Red Cross, wouldn't you also have to blame him for murder and rape? These things are either the result of free will or they aren't, no?.

    And for the last time, if you do both credit and blame God for cancer, natural disasters, and credit him for sunshine and rainbows, and pretty flowers etc, do you really think that can even out and make him overall Good, even when he has absolute unlimited power?

    You still refuse to read the Book of Spiderman, don't you? With great power should come great responsibility. If God wasn't all powerful, then we could understand why stuff like cancer could exist. But if he's all powerful, and the guy purposefully made cancer exist, that's one evil deity, and no amount of rainbows or sunshine or pretty flowers could change that.
     
    Last edited: Aug 8, 2020
    Ronald Hillman likes this.
  20. trevorw2539

    trevorw2539 Well-Known Member Past Donor

    Joined:
    Jul 15, 2013
    Messages:
    8,299
    Likes Received:
    1,257
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Just for your information I have never read Bart Erhman or other Chriistain Liberals. I have deliberately stayed away from either side of the argument and used books dealing with facts, history and archaeology - and of course - the Jewish Bible. (OT). You have never refuted any of my factual offerings except to refuse them without even researching them and explaining you reason. Could it be you have no reason.

    JAG States What many Atheists Say: Your evidence for many? You've asked MANY or is it one of those 'I Guess how many?
    {1) I am an atheist. I am an atheist
    {2} i don't believe in God. Therefore I don't believe in God
    {3} But He may exist. I don't believe he does.
    {4} I can't prove He does. I don't believe he does
    {5} I can't prove He doesn't. I don't believe he does.
    {6} The Bible says He is Omnipotent. Whatever the Bible says is simply man's imagination
    {7} That means He is all powerful. Man's imagination again
    {8} He could have created a different world. There is no God
    {9} But He did not do that. There is no God.
    {10} He created the world we now have. Irrelevant
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists. Ditto
    {12} Therefore God is responsible for bone cancer in children. Ditto
    {13} I want to be consistent with this principle.Irelevant
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross He doesn't exist.

    If anyone agrees with Jags list he is not an atheist but an agnostic.

    The above points are all relevant only to those who believe. It's a hypothetical situation set up by yourself for your own satisfaction. Your God is one of 100's of hypothetical Gods. We are nearer to proving that 'gods' are the products of superior earlier civilisations. The Biblical story of Adam and the genealogy regarding this myth is certainly problematic when we have proof of civilisations thousands of year before.
     
    Jolly Penguin and Ronald Hillman like this.
  21. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    I have a very strong leg to stand on.
    Here is that strong leg.
    If 11 is true . . . then 14 is also true.

    Totally irrelevant.
    I ask them to change their structure.
    They can say Yes or No.
    I DO ask them to change their structure.
    I DO ask them to state 14 if they state 11
    This is 100% logical and 100% reasonable.

    If 11 is true
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.

    Then 14 is true
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross

    It does not matter what atheists believe.
    It does not matter what atheists NOW believe.
    I ask , , ASK , , them to change their beliefs.
    The can say Yes or No.
    I can keep on ASKING.
    If they post 6 - 12 in threads that I have every logical right to REQUEST that
    they also state 14.

    If they post 6 -12 in threads that means they posted 11 , ,

    , , , and here is what 11 says:
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.

    And if 11 is true , ,

    Then 14 is true
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross

    It does not matter what "their position is."
    I ASK them to change their minds about what "their position is."
    I make a REQUEST that they do this.
    Do what?
    Do this:
    If they state that 11 is true , , then I ASK them to state that 14 is also true.


    I am not sure I understand your question.
    However, my position on this is quite simple:

    If they post 6 -12 in threads that means they posted 11 , ,

    , , , and here is what 11 says:
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.

    And if 11 is true , ,

    Then 14 is true
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross

    JAG

    Regarding your "hospitals and kelp" question:
    I see it as totally irrelevant because 11
    clearly says "That means He {God} is responsible for ALL that exists"
    and that include kelp, hair, peat moss, cheese, chickens, cows, and
    everything else.

    We have a very simple idea here.
    God is either responsible for ALL that exists , , or , , God is NOT.
    If God is, then God is responsible for cancer and Hospitals
    and the Red Cross and warm sandy beaches and your air
    conditioner and your comfortable home.


    ``
     
  22. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    Bart is not a "Christian liberal."
    Bart is not a Christian.
    He is a Christian apostate.
    Like Judas.
    A turncoat.

    False.
    Your "facts" are not facts.

    .
    False.
    Atheists say 6-12 in Forums on the Internet At Large all the time.
    You do NOT know what you are talking about.
    Fact.

    JAG
     
    Last edited: Aug 8, 2020
  23. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    False.
    You deliberately and willfully choose to refuse to see the truth of this
    below:

    JAG States What Many Atheists Say:
    {1) I am an atheist.
    {2} i don't believe in God.
    {3} But He may exist.
    {4} I can't prove He does.
    {5} I can't prove He doesn't.
    {6} The Bible says He is Omnipotent.
    {7} That means He is all powerful.
    {8} He could have created a different world.
    {9} But He did not do that.
    {10} He created the world we now have.
    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.
    {12} Therefore God is responsible for bone cancer in children.
    {13} I want to be consistent with this principle.
    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross
    ___________

    This below is solid , ,
    This below is airtight , ,
    This below is water-proof , , ,
    There is a principle stated in 11 , , ,
    What principle?
    The principle that God is responsible for all that exists.

    {11} That means He is responsible for all that exists.

    {14} Therefore God is also responsible for Hospitals and the Red Cross


    Remember many atheists DO postulate that God does exist for the sake of argument
    and then they DO say 1 through 11 is true , , ,

    , , , and if 11 is true then 14 is also true.

    So?

    So the God-That-Does-Not-Exist is responsible
    for cancer and Hospitals and the Red Cross.
    Fact.

    JAG

    _________

    Continue to evade and misdirect and deliberately cloud the issue.
    Your "atheist buddies" are cheering you on.
    That "little tiny band of angry venom-posting atheists" are on your side.
    They will tell you how smart you are.
    They will continue to give you their "Thank You's" : because you
    are "one of them" --- "birds of a feather flock together."

    Just remember this: They will NOT "be there for you" when it
    really counts. When you lay dying on your Death Bed your "friends"
    will NOT be there to comfort you. For one thing they have no
    words of comfort for you or for themselves or for anybody else.

    You at 81 will soon come to know if you have "played the
    whirlwind" and have lost your soul. "What shall it
    profit a man," said the Lord Jesus, "if he shall gain the
    whole world and yet lose his own soul." Your "books"
    and your so-called "facts" will be of no comfort to you
    in the very near future. There are a mere 120 months
    in ten years --- so its highly likely that you will find out
    very soon if you made an eternally soul-destroying
    choice/decision when you turned your back on the
    God that created you and went after your so-called
    "facts,"

    JAG
     
  24. JAG*

    JAG* Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 20, 2015
    Messages:
    2,035
    Likes Received:
    425
    Trophy Points:
    83
    You do not know that,
    It is incorrect to claim that you know that God does not exist.
    Why don't you prove it?
    You made the claim.
    You said point blank that "He doesn't exist."
    That is a Faith belief.
    The Reverend Trevor hath spoken.
    The Reverend Trevor hath preached a sermon.
    Twas a short sermon, but still a Faith-based sermon.
    "He doesn't exist"___The Reverend Trevor

    Prove # 1 to be wrong down below , , , and 2 through 8 will be yours to enjoy.

    All you have to do is demonstrate with Empirical evidence that God does not
    exist and thereby prove # 1 to be false.

    {1} You can not demonstrate with Empirical evidence that God does not exist.
    {2} If you could do that, you'd be a $ millionaire in just a few weeks.
    {3} You would also win many secular awards and prizes.
    {4} You would be on national television prime time constantly.
    {5} You would be invited to be a guest on all the cable news channels.
    (6) You would become the most famous man in all of human history.
    (7} You would be the man that had, at last, eliminated Theism off the planet.
    {8} Just think. You can eliminate:
    Christianity
    Islam
    Judaism , , ,

    , , ,off the planet once and for all , , ,
    , , ,and all you have to do is just produce your evidence that there is no God.

    Millions of dollars and world fame awaits the atheist that can prove there
    is no God and vanish , , ,
    Christianity
    Islam
    Judaism , , ,
    , , ,off the planet once and for all.

    Do this and Trevor will be the hero of atheism/Secularism world-wide.

    But you don't really want the $ millions of dollars and world fame.

    Yeah right!


    ___________

    You would have to be Omniscient and Omnipresent in order to KNOW
    that God does not exist.

    You are neither.

    So?

    So you do not know that God does not exist,

    JAG

    PS
    You posted a quote by Dookins that said Faith was dangerous.

    Dookins cited 9/11 when the fanatics flew those airplanes into
    those buildings. Come on Trevor, and prove that "He doesn't exist"
    and rid the world once and for all of that dangerous Theism.

    What's the matter? Don't you want to do Humanity a very important
    service?

    Don't you want $millions of dollars so that you can create
    The Atheist Foundation to teach people that atheists like Dookins
    ought to be worshiped as one of the gods of Secular Humanism?

    Don't you want "world fame" so you can "get the message out there"
    that Secular Humanism is the one true religion and the one true Faith?

    {1} You can not demonstrate with Empirical evidence that God does not exist.

    All ya gotta do is produce Empirical Evidence that # 1 up there is wrong.
    Come on and "cough it up."

    JAG
     
  25. trevorw2539

    trevorw2539 Well-Known Member Past Donor

    Joined:
    Jul 15, 2013
    Messages:
    8,299
    Likes Received:
    1,257
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Just remember this: They will NOT "be there for you" when it
    really counts. When you lay dying on your Death Bed your "friends"
    will NOT be there to comfort you. For one thing they have no
    words of comfort for you or for themselves or for anybody else.

    You at 81 will soon come to know if you have "played the
    whirlwind" and have lost your soul. "What shall it
    profit a man," said the Lord Jesus, "if he shall gain the
    whole world and yet lose his own soul." Your "books"
    and your so-called "facts" will be of no comfort to you
    in the very near future. There are a mere 120 months
    in ten years --- so its highly likely that you will find out
    very soon if you made an eternally soul-destroying
    choice/decision when you turned your back on the
    God that created you and went after your so-called
    "facts,"

    Were you there when Jesus said that?

    Death is a fact of life I've had, so far, 81 years which I have mainly enjoyed. I don't have a belief in life after death, but who knows. The simple fact is that you rely on an unproven being for a future existence.On the other hand the Buddhists are aware of the FACT that the energy that keeps our bodies going cannot die. It changes form. They believe this becomes part of the universal energy. Is there a spirit world? who knows. Most religions seem to rely on some sort of life. There is no reason to suppose either way. Most certainly I do not believe in hell, and neither do many Christians now. It was a way of controlling the masses.

    By the way it's quite usual for people like yourself to threaten in this way.

    And your refusal of Facts is just proof that you have no idea what you are talking about. Biblical Genealogy puts Adam and Eve around 4000 BCE That date being known as Anno Mundi .(Year of the World- or its beginning) Unfortunately for your thinking there are civilisations and cities that stretch back farther than that. And that is recognised by Christians and atheists alike. It is a proven fact however much you deny it.

    I've asked many Christians over the years one particular question - and never got a satisfactory answer that fits the actual facts. What actually happened to Jesus after his birth

    Matthew puts the Family of Jesus in Egypt shortly after his birth to escape Herod. There he stays until Herods death. He is then taken back to Israel, but not to Bethlehem we are told, because of the new King -who was actually as bad, or worse than his father and got sent to Gaul as punishment for his deeds against the Jews. Instead he was sent to Nazareth. Now this is odd. Why specifically mention sending him to Nazareth instead, when that was Josephs home anyway..The trip to Jerusalem we are told is supposed to fulfil Hosea 1:1. This verse refers clearly and unequivocally to Israel. If it refers to Jesus then Jesus must have fulfilled the rest of the chapter, which is full of worshipping idols etc. Taking one verse out of context destroys the validity of the Bible. Matthew does this often.

    Luke however puts the family in Nazareth 40 days after Jesus birth. This is the reference to Mary's cleansing after birth. There Jesus remains until he at least reaches adulthood (13). No mention of Egypt.

    So where was Jesus? In both place at once? Another miracle? There was no way the family could have walked to Egypt and returned in 40 days give Mary's condition and looking after a newborn. Besides the child had to be circumcised on the 8th day and also to be redeemed at the Temple - being the firstborn son. Not only this but Herod the Great is still alive.

    Odd, ain't it.

    Forget the facts Jag and make it up as you go along.
     

Share This Page