Self Managed Abortions

Bowerbird · Sep 1, 2022

kazenatsu said: ↑

No. My point was that shifting the argument to something else does not mean my specific argument is wrong. That's not a rebuttal to my specific argument.
So if I start an abortion thread to discuss one specific argument within the abortion debate, trying to shift the argument is just going off topic.

If I make an argument, for example, that a person cannot use their body to kill someone else, then that type of argument obviously presumes that there is another "someone else" involved. It's true that if there were no "someone else" my argument would be rendered a moot point in the overall wider argument, but that still would not mean my specific argument is wrong. It is not a rebuttal to my specific argument. It's actually just an attempt to generalize the argument in the debate and make it about abortion.

Hope that's not too "complicated" for anyone to follow.
Click to expand...

Let us invert your “argument”

is a person obligated to use their body to keep another person alive?

FoxHastings · Sep 1, 2022

kazenatsu said: ↑

No. My point was that shifting the argument to something else does not mean my specific argument is wrong. That's not a rebuttal to my specific argument.
So if I start an abortion thread to discuss one specific argument within the abortion debate, trying to shift the argument is just going off topic.

If I make an argument, for example, that a person cannot use their body to kill someone else, then that type of argument obviously presumes that there is another "someone else" involved. It's true that if there were no "someone else" my argument would be rendered a moot point in the overall wider argument, but that still would not mean my specific argument is wrong. It is not a rebuttal to my specific argument. It's actually just an attempt to generalize the argument in the debate and make it about abortion.

Hope that's not too "complicated" for anyone to follow.
Click to expand...

FoxHastings said: ↑
THERE IS NO "SOMEONE" IN HER WOMB.

Hope that's not too "complicated" for anyone to follow...but it seems to be...

Log in or Sign up

Self Managed Abortions

Bowerbird Well-Known Member

FoxHastings Well-Known Member

Share This Page

Log in or Sign up

Self Managed Abortions

Bowerbird Well-Known Member

FoxHastings Well-Known Member

Share This Page

Useful Searches